Three Visions for African Americans

In the early years of the 20th century, Booker T. Washington, W. E. B. Du Bois and Marcus Garvey developed competing visions for the future of African Americans.


- Civil War Reconstruction failed to assure full rights of citizens to free slaves.

o By 1890s KKK terrorism, lynchings, racial segregation laws, etc were mockery of 13th, 14th, 15th amendments passed after Civil War.



Booker T. Washington

- Born a slave on Virginia plantation, explaining his advocation of submission.

o Self-made man

- Designed, developed and guided the Tuskegee Institute

o Emphasized agricultural and industrial training.

o Advocated that blacks to put aside immediate demands for voting and ending racial segregation.

- In his Atlanta Address, he accepted the reality of racial segregation but insisted that blacks be included in the economic progress of the South.

o “In all things social we can be as separate as the fingers yet one as the hand in all things essential to mutual progress”.

o “No race that has anything to contribute to the markets of the world is long in any degree ostracized

- 2 important quotes in the Atlanta Address.

- Widely accepted by whites.

o Had aid of philanthropists including Andrew Carnegi.

- Controlled a number of newspapers including the New York Age and attacked anyone who questioned his vision.




W.E.B Du Bois

- Born as a free black in Massachusetts, a liberal state in the North.

- Envisioned the creation of The Talented Tenth, educated black leaders who would lead blacks to securing equal rights and higher economic standards.

- Attacked Washington’s acceptance of racial segregation, arguing that this only encourages whites to deny blacks the right to vote and undermine their pride and progress.

o Lynchings and riots against blacks led to formation of NAACP which he co-founded.

o Editor of the organization’s journal, The Crisis.

§ Would be famous for the court case Brown v. Board of Education which overturned Plessey v. Ferguson.

- Used the Crisis to attack Booker T. Washington, but by by the time of his death his Tuskegee vision had lost influence among many African Americans.

- Du Bois would become disillusioned and join the US Communist Party – the only party to provide equal rights for all.




Marcus Garvey

- Founded the Universal Negro Improvement Association (UNIA).

o Stressed racial pride and self improvement

o Garvey was an admirer of Washington.

- Had greater international ambitions including development of black-owned industries and shipping lines.

o Early success was The Black Star Line, first black owned shipping company in the United States.

o Publicity over the Black Star Line caused Garvey to promote this and other UNIA projects.

- 1920 over 20,000 people attended Garvey’s first UNIA convention.

o The Declaration of Negro Rights was issued which denounced lynchings, segregated public transportation, job discrimination and inferior black public schools.

§ Also demanded “Africa for Africans”.

o Without consulting any black people, they named Garvey the “Provisional President of Africa”.

- HV believed that whites would never accept black Americans as equals.

o Therefore called for separate self-development of blacks in the United States.

- Urged blacks to return to Africa including settling them in Liberia, the only African nation governed by Africans.

o HV lacked the necessary funds and few blacks had any interests in returning to Africa.

- Garvey declared that goals of UNIA and KKK were the same – completely separate black and white societies.

o Criticism among his followers grew.

- Poor economy and near-bankruptcy of Black Star Line eventually got Garvey arrested for mail fraud in attempts to sell more stock in failing company

o Trail proved he was a poor businessman, but jury convicted him anyways and he was sentenced to prison.




The Future of the Civil Rights

- Visions of Washington, Du Bois, and Garvey fell short of settling future of black people in Amer. Society.

o In mid-20th, Martin Luther King Jr. would pursue strategy of non-violence.

o Leaders of NAACP including Thurgood Marshall worked through legal cases.

o Militant stands included the Black Muslims led by Elijah Muhammad which advocated separation.

§ Malcom X broke from the muslims and formed rival faction opposing separation.

§ Black Panthers led by Huey Newton would prepare for revolution.

0 comments: