Chapter 41 The Resurgence of Conservatism


o Average Amer. Older in 1960s and much more likely to live in South and West.

o Conservative cause added to “New Right” movement.

o Counter to protests of 1960s cultural.

o Led by Christian groups incl. Moral Majority.

o Against abortion, porn, homosexuality, feminism, affirmative action.

The Election of Ronald Reagan 1980

o Reagan denounced activist gov and “social engineering” of 1960s

o Championed “common man”

o Depicted big gov as villain.

o Drew on ideas of neoconservatives

§ Includes Norman Podhoretz of Commentary and

§ Irving Kristol of The Public Interest.

§ Championed free-market capitalism free from gov restrains.

§ Harshly anti-Soviet positions in foreign policy.

o 1980 Repubs ready to challenge Democrats hold on White House

o Carter inability to control double digit inflation.

o Own democratic had ABC Anybody but Carter movement.

o Edward Kennedy and Carter ran for Democrats.

o Reagan advantage of TV “debate” w/ Carter.

o High interest, inflation, failing economy put president on defensive.

o Independent John Anderson 7% of popular votes.

o Repubs gain control of Senate for 1st time in 25 years.

o Carter farewell address to scale down arms race, promote human rights, protect environment

o Last things signed bill preserving 100 mil acres of Alaska land for national parks, forests, wildlife refuges.

The Reagan Revolution

o Inauguration Day = release of hostages

o 444 days of captivity

o Secretary of interior James Watt

o Product of Sagebrush Rebellion anti-Washington movement to protest federal control over rich mineral and timber resources in western states.

o Attempted to go around EPA to permit oil drilling.

o Forced to resign through ethnic joke.

o Reagan: “The government is not the solution to our problem. Government is the problem.”

o Previously fed spending ^ 18% of GNP to 23%, composition of federal budget shift from defense to entitlement programs incl. social security and medicare

o 4 decades of New Deal and Great Society = countercurrent.

§ California tax revolt 1978 Proposition 13

§ To kill welfare state.

o Federal budget to cut $35 billion mostly in social programs.

o Got support of southern conservative Democrats boll weevils

o Attacked, recovered 12 days.

The Battle of the Budget

o Dismantling of welfare state

o Demonstrated power of presidency.

o Deep tax cuts 25% across the boat reductions over 3 years.

o Support from “boll weevils” enable this.

o 1981 far-reaching tax reforms that lowered individual tax rates, reduced federal estate taxes and created new tax-free savings plans for small investors.

o Supply side economics worked in theory as new investment would boost productivity, foster dramatic economic growth and reduce federal deficit.

o But “Reagan recession” of 1982

o Automobile industry horrible performance

§ Conflict w/ Japanese imports

o Actually anti-inflationary “tight money” policies by Federal Reserve Board in Carter started.

o “Reaganomics”.

o 1980s economy not sound.

o First time in 1900s gap b/w rich and poor increased.

o “yuppies” young urban professionals emerged.

§ = values of materialism and pursuit of wealth.

o 1980s some say massive military expenditures was real foundation of prosperity.

o Against arms frace v. Soviet Union.

o Federal budgest topped $100 billion 1982, gov’s books nearly $200 billion out of balance.

o A lot of borrowing from other nations = interest rates high.

o Bad for US exporters, good for buyers of foreign cars.

o US soon world’s heaviest borrowers.

Reagan Renews the Cold War

o USSR as “focus evil” of the modern world”

o Strategy to expand US military capabilities, could threaten USSR w/ expensive round of Cold War.

o Strategic Defense Initiative

§ Aka Star Wars

§ Battle stations that could fire laser beams and vaporize intercontinental ballistic missiles on liftoff.

§ Scientists considered as impossible goal

· Emphasized defense more than offense

· Upset 40 years of strategic thinking about nuclear weaponry.

§ Constrained congressional funding for SDI.

o USSR and Poland.

o Poland organized into massive union Solidarity, clamped martial law on country.

o Reagan = economic sanctions on Poland and USSR.

§ Resumption of grain embargo on USSR.

o Oligarchs in Kremlin also dying

o Korean passenger airliner blasted from Societ airspace.

o By 1983 all arms-control negotiations broken off.

o Western boycott of Moscow Olympics and USSR and satellite states boycotting of Los Angeles Olympic Games

Troubles Abroad

o Israel strained relationship w/ US

o Invaded Lebanon to suppress guerilla bases

o Reagan sends US troops to Lebanon as part of int’l peacekeeping force.

§ United States Marine barracks

o “Teflon President” b/c Reagan wasn’t hurt.

o Leftist revolution in Nicaragua.

o Anti-American Sandinistas government.

o Reagan sent CIA helped “contra rebels” opposing anti-US government of Nicaragua.

o Dispatched powerful invasion of Grenada to overturn Marxist government.

Round Two for Reagan

o Democrat Walter Mondale VP Congresswomen first ever Geraldine Ferraro

o Foreign policies dominated

o New Soviet leader Gorbachev announced Glasnost “openness” and Prestroika or “restructuring”

§ Openness: Aimed to remove repressive stuffiness of USSR by introducing free speecdh.

§ Restructuring = revive USSR economy by adopting free-market practices.

o Glasnost and Prestroika required that USSR shrink size of military machine and direct energy to civilian economy

o Required Cold War to end.

o USSR to cease intermediate range nuclear forces INF targeted on Western Europe.

o Four Geneva Summit Meetings 1985

o First stopped INF

o 2nd broke down in stalemate

o 3rd signed INF treaty banning all intermediate-range nuclear missiles from Europe.

o 4th Reagan praised Gorbachev.

o Reagan backed Aquino’s overthrow of dictator Marcos in Phillipines

o Lightning air raid against Libya

o US naval vessels to escort oil tankers through Persian Gulf due to Iran-Iraq War.

The Iran-Contra Imbroglio

o Continuing captivity of US hostages seized by Muslim extremists.

o Lebanon troubles

o Left-wing Sandinista gov in Nicaragua.

o Congress refuses to aid contra rebels fighting against Sandinista regime.

o Iran-Contra scandal

o Sells arms to Iranians, uses money to violate congressional ban on military aid to Nicaraguan rebels and aid them.

§ North marine colonel, NSC Poindexter and Secretary of Defense Weinberger convicted, eventually reversed.

§ Weinberger pardoned.

o Reagan emerged as lazy, sometimes sleeped.

o But remained most popular

Reagan’s Economic Legacy

o Major tax reform bills 1981 – 1986

o Revenue hole of $200 billion annual deficits

o $2 trillion added to national debt.

o As debt was financed by foreign lenders, esp. Japanese, guaranteed that future generations of US would have to work harder than parents or lower of standard of paying.

o 1986 Congress pass legislation mandating balanced budget by 1991.

o Ineffective.

o New social spending practically, politically impossible = containment of welfare state.

o Reversal of long-term trend towards distribution of income.

The Religious Right

o Evangelical Christians

o Reverend Jerry Falwell founded Moral Majority

o Against abortion, feminism, spread of gay rights.

o Huge audiences, aggressive advocates of conservative causes.

o Religious rights aka “movement conservatives”.

o Declared themselves pro-life voters, had prayer meetings, right to life movement, protesters in 1980s blocked entrances to abortion clinics

Conservatism in the Courts

o Courts principle instrument in “culture wars”

o Reagan appointed near-majority of all judges.

o Incl. Sandra Day O’Conner women.

o Against affirmative action and abortion.

o Court ruled union rules about job seniority could outweight AA concerns in promotion policies in fire dep.

o Ward’s Cove Packing v. Antonia and Martin v. Wilks = more difficult to prove employer practiced racial discrimination and hiring, easier for white males to argue they were victims of reverse discrimination.

o 1991 partially reversed.

o Roe v. Wade legalized abortion.

o Webster v. Reproductive Health Service did not overturn Roe, but compromised protection of abortion rights.

o Planned Parenthood v. Casey ruled states could restrict access to abortion as long as they did not place “undue burden” on women.

Referendum on Reaganism in 1988

o Lost control of Senate 1986

o New Democratic majority rejected Robert Bork (Reagan’s ultraconservative nominee for Supreme Court)

o Removed unethical behavior in Reagan’s “official family”

o Top EPA officials, Reagan’s secretary of labor, White House aid stepped down.

o Attorney General Edwin Meese under prosecution.

o Economic trouble

o Federal budget deficit and international trade deficit continued to mount

o Falling oil prices = bad for SW econ.

o Loans become useless.

o Damages to S&L institutions.

o Federal assistance required to save Continental Illinois Bank.

o Mergers, buyouts over Wallstreet.

o Increased gap b/w rich and poor

o Black Monday Oct. 19 1987 leading stockmarket went down.

o Democrats wanted to take advantage of this = “Seven Dwarfs”

o Jesse Jackson black candidate, w/ “rainbow coalition” of minorities.

o Gary Hart went out after charges of sexual misconduct.

o Michael Dukakis nomination.

o Repubs nominate George Bush

o Reagan record of tax cuts

o Strong defense policies

o Toughness on crime

George Bush and the End of the Cold War

o Deepest commitment to public service

o Emissary to China, ambassador to UN, director of CIA, VP.

o “kinder, gentler America”

o Tiananmen Square Massacre

o US should condemn, but Bush insisted on maintaining normal relations w/ China.

o Solidarity Movement in Poland toppled communist gov

o Soon communist gov in Hungary, Czechoslovakia, East Germany, and Romania.

o Wall comes down 1989

o Two Germanies unite.

o Symbolic end to Cold War

o Gorbachev’s policies set in motion out of control.

o Military coup attempts to overthrow, w/ help of Yeltsin foils plot, but then dissolves and Soviet Unnion dissolved into component parts into the commonwealth of Independent States.

o Yeltsin dominant leader.

o All new gov relatively free-market economy, democratices.

o Bush spoke hopefully of “new world order” where demo reign and diplomacy supersede weaponry.

o START II accord w/ Yeltsin, both powers to reduce long-=range nuclear arsenals 2/3 within 2 years.

o After USSR disintegrates, nationalistic fervor and ethnic racial hatrest.

o Chechyan massacres.

o Yugoslavia “ethnic cleansing”

o German economy has to absorb backwards economically, physically East.

o US foreign policy left with no direction.

o Expensive orders for military bases and navy attack plans canceled.

o California hard hit where defense plants shut their doors.

o Democracy went forward.

o Nelson Mandela in South Africa

o Free elections in Nicaragua.

The Persian Gulf Crisis

o Bush suppresses dictator Noriega in Panama

o Saddam Hussein to overrun Kuwait for oil

o Iraq needed to pay war bills from Iran-Iraq war.

o US and allies had previously funded Iraq b/c against Iran.

o After attack UNSC condemned invasion, send immediate and unconditional withdrawal of Iraq troops.

o US spearheaded massive int’l military development.

o US soldiers, many women and members of new, post-Vietnam, all volunteer military, to Persian Gulf.

Fighting “Operation Desert Storm”

o US general Schwarzkopf

o Iraq had chemical, bio weapons.

o Saddam ignited oil-well fires

o Schwarzkopf relentlessly bombed, tidal-wave of troops.

o Operation Desert Storm 4 days and much of Iraq’s remaining fighting force quickly destroyed or captured.

o Kuwait liberated

o Welcomed as heroes.

o Failed to dislodge Saddam Hussein from power.

Bush on the Home Front

o “kindler, gentler America” > Americans with Disabilities Act

o prohibiting discrimination against Amer w/ physical or mental disabilities.

o Major water projects bill 1992 reforming distribution of subsidized federal water in West.

§ Interests of environment ahead of agriculture.

o Bush challenged legality of college scholarships targeted for racial minorities

o Threatened to veto civil rights legislation that would make it easier for employees to prove discrimination in hiring and promotion practices.

o Nominated Clarence Thomas

§ Opposed by liberal groups incl. labor, NAACP, National Organization for Women (NOW)

§ Presumed opposition to abortion rights.

o Senate Judiciary Committee concluded w/ divided 7-7 vote and no recommendation.

o Anita Hill charges against Clarence Thomas for sexual harassment.

§ Senate vote roughly made it pass

§ Robert Packwood later to fall victim.

o Conflict over Clarence Thomas suggested social issues that helped 3 Repub victories losing electoral appeal.

o Gender gap = women for democrats more.

o 1992 employment rate exceeded 7%

o 1990 budget agreement incl. $133 bil in new taxes

o so “read my lips, no new taxes”a failure.

o Members of House written “bad checks”

o Movement to impose limits on number of terms.

Bill Clinton: The First Baby-Boomer President

o Problems: economy, widening gender gap.

o Bill Clinton and Al Gore

o Claimed to be a “New Democrat” who was primarily centrist

o Formed Democratic Leadership Council to point towards progrowth, strong defense, anticrime policies.

o To stimulate econ, reform welfare, reform health-care system.

o Republicans George Bush and Danforth Quayle.

o By 1992 voters more concerned about economy.

o “It’s the economy, stupid”.

o Ross Perot stole votes from Bush, attacked problem of federal deficit.

o Strongest independent showing since TR on Bull Moose 1912.

o Clinton

o First baby boomer.

o Democrats majorities in both houses of Congress.

o Moseley-Braun first African American woman elected to US Senate

§ 5 other women in Senate

o Many women in Clinton’s cabinet.

o Attorney general = Reno

o Secretary of health, human services Shalala

o Racial minorities Cisneroes and black ron Brown as secretary of commerce.

o Ginsburg to Supreme Court, another woman.

A False Start for Reform

o Advocate end of ban on gays and lesbians in armed services

o Resulted in “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy.

o Attempt to fix health-care system

o Hillary Clinton in charge of it

o Very complicated, DOA for Congress.

o Very active for First Lady, but midway after first term sidestepped.

o Clinton deficit-reduction bill 1993

o Federal deficit to lowest level in more than decade

o Brady Bill for gun control and $30 bil anticrime bill.

o Against rising violence

o Muslim attack on World Trade Center 1993

o Oklahoma City Bombings

§ Claim to be b/c of fed standing in Waco and fundamentalist Branch Davidians.

o Due to antigovernment sentiment.

o 23 states restrictions on elected officials.

The Politics of Distrust

o Newt Gingrich offered “Contrast w/ America”

o 1994 every Repub candidate reelected.

o Control of both chambers of federal Congress for first time in 40 years.

o Repub Congress restricted “unfounded mandates”, fed laws that imposed new obligations on state and local gov w/o providing new revenues.

o Clinton reluctantly signed Welfare Reform Bill deep cuts in welfare grants and req. welfare recipients to find employment.

o Restricted welfare benefits for immigrants

o Due to rising anti-immigration.

o To accommodate electorate’s conservative mood.

o Tense confrontation b/w Repub congress and Democratic president

o Fed gov had to sut down for several days 1995.

o Clinton’s Reelection campaign raised a lot of money

o Republican opposition Robert Dole.

o Ross Perot attempted again, less than half votes.

o Republicans remained in control of Congress

Clinton Again

o Promises of far-reaching reform no longer heard.

o Modest goals, though tax revenues by economy produced 1998 balanced federal budget for first time in 30 years.

o Claims political middle ground

o Cali 1996 approved Proposition 209 prohibiting AA preferences in gov and higher education

o Hopwood v. Texas had a similar effect in Texas

o Clinton criticized, but didn’t try to reverse them

§ AA support diminished.

o By 2000 economy longest growth in US history.

o Inflationary pressure remained very low.

o 1997 South East Asia econ crisis

o US surged ahead w/ new Internet business.

o Supported North American Free Trade Agreement.

o Opposition of protectionists in own party, fear to lose jobs to low-wage Mexican workers.

o Clinton > promoted creation of World Trade Organization successor to General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade.

o Opposition to trade policy

o Campaign finance reform 1996 presidential campaign issue!

o Both parties dependent on vast sums.

o John McCain campaign finance reform centerpiece of bid to presidential nomination.

o Fights against big tobacco and for gun control in Clinton second term.

o Wouldn’t let tobacco companies win immunity from litigation.

o Later hoped lawsuits would force tobacco industry to reimburse fed gov.

o Gun control – Columbine High School shooting.

o Clinton debate against National Rifle Association

Problems Abroad

o Found out that some CIA officials sold secrets to Soviets

o Executions of US agents abroad.

o Peacekeeping mission to Somalia, reinforced US troops there after Somali rebels killed Amers.

o Ethnic violence in Rwanda.

o Haiti democratically elected president Aristide deposed by military coup 1992.

o US troops to return him to presidency.

o Clinton previously wanted to punish China for demo abuses, but too important in economy.

o 2000 China trade bill made China trading partner of US.

o Balkans and Yugoslavians.

o Sent NATO troops.

o NATO expansion to incl. Poland, Hungary, Czech Republic 1997.

o Serbia’s Milsevic unleashes “ethnic cleansing” in Kosovo, NATO air war.

o Eventually stopped it.

o Middle East foreign issues.

o Yitzhak Rabin and PLO leader Yasir Arafat agreed on self-rule for Palestinians in Israel.

o Rabin assassinated, Clinton secretary of state Albright to broker permanent settlement.

o Hussein refuse to let UN inspect Iraqi weapons program.

o US Britain air strikes against Iraqi weapons factories.

o US also attack Afghanistan and Sudan for terrorist bombings there.

o Attempts peace at Northern Ireland and Korea, and travel to India and Pakistan to reduce rivalry.

Scandal and Impeachment

o Whitewater Land Corporation Clinton’s rol suspicious.

o Foster Jr. close Clinton associate suicided.

o President’s loose ethics in Primary Colors.

o Scandal w/ Monica Lewinsky

o Lawsuit brought on by Paula Jones when charged that Clinton sexually harassed her.

o Jones case led to windfall of prosecutor Starr originally to investigate Whitewater deal.

o Then Clinton admitted, and passed 2 articles of impeachment: perjury before grand jury and obstruction of justice.

o Prosecutors for Senate trial led by Hyde claimed perjury and obstruction grave issues that nothing less than “rule of law” at stake.

o Majority thought was a low folly, not a high crime.

o 1998 Repubs lose House majority, Gingrich resigns.

o Clinton’s job approval remains high.

o Rehnquist presided over court case.

Clinton’s Legacy

o Protected many lands, public support for health-care improvements in form of “patient’s bill of rights”

o 100,000 more teachers, 50,000 more police officers.

o Repubs wanted big tax cuts, Democrats wanted smaller cuts and new ways to increase Medicare and Social Security = key conflicts for 2000 presidential campaign.

o First term economic growth succeeded.

o Full employment by decade’s end

o Poverty rates down

o Median income new highs

o Social justice and racial harmony alive.

The Bush-Gore Presidential Battle

o Al Gore with Lieberman critic of Clinton during Lewinsky affair.

o Lieberman first Jew nominated to national ticket by major party.

o Green Party Ralph Nader threatened to get votes off environmentalists which would have been off Gore.

o George W. Bush promised to return “2/3” of surplus “to the people”

o Championed school vouchers, allowing individual workers to invest part of payroll taxes in private retirement accounts.

o State of Florida

o Jeb Bush as governor.

o Republican dominated Florida legislatures to name a set of pro-Bush electors

o Court’s 5 most conservative members ruled in Bush’s favor when it was taken to Supreme Court.

o Senate 50 50 b/w Demos and Republicans

o Hillary Clinton first First Lady to run for office, wins Senate seat.

o Relatively peaceful transition, democracy persists.

0 comments: